We live in a world of instant answers. When we face a problem, our first move is to grab our phones and ask Google or ChatGPT. Our kids do the same thing. But this habit might be taking away something important from their growth.
Let’s talk about something that might sound strange. A little bit of struggle is actually good for your tween when they’re learning.
The Power of Productive Struggle
When we say “struggle,” we don’t mean extreme frustration. We’re talking about that sweet spot where learning feels challenging but not impossible. The answer doesn’t come easily, but it’s within reach.
Here’s what happens when your child works through tough tasks. They remember them differently than when they just Google the answer. This deeper learning sticks because they had to work for it.
Think of it this way. It’s always “easy plus one.” That stretching and wrestling with new ideas helps your kids really understand them. This makes them ready for bigger challenges later.
Why Surface Learning Doesn’t Stick
Here’s a common example with grammar. Your child can find nouns, verbs, and adjectives in a workbook. They can pass tests on sentence structure. But ask them to use that same knowledge in their own writing? They can’t do it.
Why? Because they haven’t really learned it. They learned it out of context. They never struggled with how to make a compound sentence work in their own paragraph. They never figured out how to add variety to their writing or make it interesting.
The struggle of using knowledge in real situations is where real learning happens.
Building Resilience Through Challenges
When your tween struggles with learning in a healthy way, they’re building resilience. And here’s the best part. This isn’t just about school. These are life skills.
The Schedule Example
Maybe you want your child to manage their own schoolwork. Many of us make a schedule and hand it to our child each day. But what if you said instead, “We need to get this work done this week. How do you think you could organize your days?”
Start small. Maybe just ask them to plan their math for the week.
Say they decide to skip Monday and plan everything else. By Saturday, they’re still doing homework. That’s a valuable lesson. Next week, when you ask them to plan their math, they’ll include Monday because they don’t want to work on weekends.
They’ve learned that lesson. They own it now.
Later, when Thursday night comes and friends ask them to watch a show, they face a real choice. Finish the math or risk working on the weekend again. They have to think it through and deal with whatever happens, good or bad.
That’s resilience in action.
Managing the Right Amount of Struggle
Here’s the key. You need to balance the amount of struggle. Life is hard enough without making everything too much.
Your child needs challenges that fit their abilities, maybe just a bit beyond, but not so far that they break down. When they face something tough but doable and succeed, they think, “That was hard, but I did it.” The next time something difficult comes up, they remember, “I did it before. I can do it again.”
That’s how they build resilience.
The Three-Level Approach
Three types of tasks work best.
- Something easy. This builds confidence and gets them started.
- Something moderately hard. This provides just enough challenge.
- One difficult subject. This is where deep learning and growth happens.
If everything is hard, your child feels hopeless. If everything is easy, they never build resilience. The mix teaches them to step up and work harder.
How to Encourage Productive Struggle (Practical Tips)
1. Pause Before Helping
When your child says, “I can’t do this. Can you help me?” wait before jumping in.
Instead, ask them to tell you what they’ve tried. Ask what happened when they tried that. Ask what they think they should try next.
Make them explain their thinking and try before they get help.
2. Create Manageable Challenges
Pick tasks that are just a little beyond their comfort zone. They should be able to do about 80% of it with skills they already have. That last 20% is the challenge. It won’t be perfect, and that’s okay.
3. Focus on Process First
In the real world, results matter. But when your child is first learning something new, you need to adjust your expectations. The result should show the process they went through, not perfection.
4. Model Struggle Yourself
This is the hard part. You need to take on something difficult yourself so you can show your child what productive struggle looks like.
When you’re learning something hard, like a new skill, a language, or a musical instrument, you feel the same things your child does. “I don’t know if I can do this. I’m not good enough.”
When your child says, “Mom, I just can’t do it,” your response means more when you can say, “You know what? I’m learning this hard piece on piano, and I’ve practiced this part for a week and still can’t get it. But I know I will. I can do hard things. I just need to break it down. The same is true for you.”
That understanding? It’s powerful.
Why This Matters More Than Ever
Today’s kids see so much every day. If they’re on social media, they see upsetting news and a world that looks perfect but isn’t. They need to learn how to get back up, try again, and be resilient.
If your child learns how to do this with schoolwork, those skills transfer to the rest of life.
Key Benefits of Building Resilience Through Learning
Delayed Gratification. Instead of instant Google answers, your child learns to sit with questions and work toward solutions.
Persistence Through Challenges. This is a life skill. Life is difficult, and kids who practice pushing through small struggles are ready for bigger ones.
Mental Health. A growth mindset (the idea that “I just don’t know this yet, but I can learn it”) changes failure from permanent to temporary.
Independence. If you want an independent learner, teaching your child to struggle through and push forward is essential. They’ll be able to read a textbook, think “I don’t understand this yet,” and keep working until they do.
Key Takeaways
Here are three important points to remember.
- Struggle is not the enemy. Healthy struggle is a powerful learning tool.
- Balance is key. One hard task is manageable. Five is not. You can handle some tasks while your child focuses on one difficult challenge. Then gradually shift more responsibility as they build skills.
- Focus on results, but adjust expectations. The process matters, but your tween also needs to learn that results matter too, just not perfection.
Your Challenge This Week
Think about just one area where you could step back and let your child take the lead. When they come asking for help, give it back to them.
Ask them what they’ve done so far. Ask them to show you what they’ve tried. Tell them to try three more things, then come back.
Look for chances to practice learning actively instead of just absorbing passively. Your child won’t learn history just by watching a movie, but they will remember a time period if they actively study it.
The Bottom Line
Building resilience now, in middle school, prepares your tween for life’s bigger challenges. Yes, it takes effort from you. Holding back, not giving answers, pushing your child beyond their comfort zone. They will push back. You’ll wonder if it’s worth it.
It is. 100%.
When you use this approach, you help your child become a more resilient person. That’s what will carry them through high school, college, careers, and all of life’s challenges.
Here’s the truth. We do hard things. And when your child learns to do hard things too, they become confident, capable, and independent learners ready for whatever life brings.
Want more tips for parenting tweens? Subscribe to Marina Joy’s newsletter for practical advice and resources.